Pros and Cons of Using a VPN in the USA (and How to Choose One)
September 11, 2025
Short answer: a VPN is worth using if you often connect to public Wi-Fi, want to keep your browsing private from your internet provider or network owner, or travel and need secure access to home services. It will not make you anonymous, protect you from phishing or malware on its own, or guarantee access to every streaming library. Choose a paid provider with an independently audited no-logs policy, strong encryption, and good speeds in the locations you use most.
Key Takeaways (Updated November 2026)
- Expect some slowdown: Comparitech’s Paul Bischoff told NBC that a good VPN typically slows your connection by about 5–10%, and users may also see more captchas.
- Some setups feel much worse: A Vice writer who lived with two VPN services found speeds many times slower with the VPN on and kept running into sites that misbehaved, concluding that daily VPN use can be frustrating.
- Streaming claims are hit or miss: Comparitech advises not to trust providers’ streaming-unblock claims and to test the service yourself during the money-back window.
What a VPN Does and Does Not Do
| A VPN helps with | A VPN does not |
|---|---|
| Encrypting traffic between your device and the VPN server | Make you anonymous to the websites you log in to |
| Hiding your browsing from your ISP or public Wi-Fi operator | Stop phishing, scams, or malware by itself |
| Masking your IP address from sites you visit | Prevent tracking by cookies and browser fingerprinting |
| Accessing services as if you were in another location | Guarantee access to every streaming catalog |
The FTC notes that most major websites already encrypt traffic with HTTPS, so a VPN’s main benefit is extra privacy and protection on untrusted networks.
Pros of Using a VPN
Safer public Wi-Fi
On café, airport, and hotel networks, a VPN encrypts your connection so other users or the network operator cannot easily see your traffic.
Privacy from your internet provider
Your ISP can see which sites you connect to. With a VPN, it sees only that you are connected to the VPN server.
Travel and remote access
When traveling, a VPN can help you reach services that expect a U.S. connection, such as banking sites that flag foreign logins, subject to each service’s terms.
Streaming and regional content
Some people use VPNs to access their home streaming libraries while abroad. Availability varies, and streaming services may block VPN traffic or restrict it in their terms of use.
Avoiding some throttling
If a network slows certain types of traffic, a VPN can make it harder to identify, though it cannot overcome overall network congestion.
Easy to use
Modern VPN apps connect with one tap and can be set to activate automatically on untrusted networks.
Cons of Using a VPN
Speed loss
Routing traffic through another server adds distance and encryption overhead. A good VPN with nearby servers keeps slowdowns modest; distant servers can be much slower.
You must trust the provider
A VPN shifts visibility from your ISP to the VPN company. Choose a provider with a clear no-logs policy that has been independently audited, and a track record of transparency.
Free VPNs carry risks
Free services may limit data, show ads, sell usage data, or have weak security. Some reputable providers offer limited free tiers; read privacy policies carefully.
Blocked by some services
Streaming platforms, banks, and websites may block VPN IP addresses or trigger extra verification.
Subscription cost
Paid VPNs require a subscription; long-term plans are cheaper per month but require upfront payment and often renew at higher prices.
False sense of security
A VPN does not replace strong passwords, two-factor authentication, software updates, and careful clicking.
How to Choose a VPN
- Audited no-logs policy: look for independent audits published by the provider.
- Strong protocols: modern options such as WireGuard or well-implemented OpenVPN or IKEv2.
- Kill switch: blocks internet if the VPN drops, to avoid leaks.
- Server locations and speed: servers near you and where you travel.
- Device support: apps for your phone, computer, router, and TV, and enough simultaneous connections.
- Transparent pricing: check the renewal price, not just the first-term discount, and the refund window.
- Jurisdiction and ownership: understand who owns the company and where it operates.
Who Benefits Most From a VPN?
- Frequent travelers and remote workers using public Wi-Fi.
- People who want more privacy from their ISP.
- Users who need secure connections to home networks or services.
Who May Not Need One?
- People who browse mostly at home on a secured network and use HTTPS sites.
- Users whose main concern is ad tracking, which is better addressed with browser privacy settings and blockers.
VPN Safety Tips
- Turn on the kill switch and auto-connect for untrusted networks.
- Keep the VPN app and your devices updated.
- Use a reputable password manager and two-factor authentication.
- Test for DNS or IP leaks with the provider’s tools after setup.
- Follow the terms of service of sites and streaming platforms you use.
What Real VPN Users and Security Experts Report
Spec sheets only tell part of the story. Below is what owners and independent testers have actually reported, summarized in our own words with a link to each original source so you can read the full context.
- Expect some slowdown: Comparitech’s Paul Bischoff told NBC that a good VPN typically slows your connection by about 5–10%, and users may also see more captchas. (NBC Washington)
- Some setups feel much worse: A Vice writer who lived with two VPN services found speeds many times slower with the VPN on and kept running into sites that misbehaved, concluding that daily VPN use can be frustrating. (Vice)
- Streaming claims are hit or miss: Comparitech advises not to trust providers’ streaming-unblock claims and to test the service yourself during the money-back window. (Comparitech)
- Free VPNs carry real risks: Norton warns that free VPNs tend to be slower due to crowded servers and some browser extensions redirect traffic to ad-heavy or sponsored sites. (Norton)
- Why the FTC issued guidance: The FTC published VPN tips after a 2017 study found a number of Android VPN apps contained malware, spyware or code injection. (PortSwigger Daily Swig)
Frequently Asked Questions
Is using a VPN legal in the US?
Yes, using a VPN is legal in the United States. Illegal activity remains illegal whether or not you use a VPN.
Does a VPN slow down my internet?
Usually somewhat. Choosing a nearby server and a fast protocol minimizes the impact.
Is a free VPN good enough?
For occasional light use, a limited free tier from a reputable provider can work. For regular use, a paid, audited provider is safer.
The Bottom Line
A VPN is a useful privacy tool for public Wi-Fi, travel, and keeping your browsing from your ISP, but it is not a complete security solution. Pick a reputable paid provider with audited no-logs claims, a kill switch, and fast nearby servers, and combine it with good security habits.
Boosting your home network? See the pros and cons of a Wi-Fi 7 router.
Sources
Discover more from Pros & Cons Reviews
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.