Protein Drinks: Benefits, Drawbacks and What the Research Says
October 28, 2025
Protein drinks, both powders you mix and ready-to-drink shakes, are now a mainstream part of many people’s diets. They make it easy to get 20 to 30 grams of protein in a few seconds, and research shows they can modestly boost muscle gains when combined with strength training. But they are not necessary for most people. Recent testing found heavy metals in many popular products, and some shakes are loaded with sugar or additives. This guide covers the benefits and drawbacks of protein drinks, what the research says, and how to choose a safer option.
Key Takeaways (Updated November 2026)
- A meta-analysis of 49 trials with 1,863 participants found protein supplements added about 0.3 kg of lean mass and 2.5 kg of one-rep-max strength during resistance training.
- Benefits leveled off at total protein intakes of about 1.6 g per kg of body weight per day; more protein did not add further muscle gains.
- The standard adult recommendation is 0.8 g/kg/day, and most people can meet it, or even higher targets, with food alone.
- Consumer Reports’ 2025 testing of 23 protein powders and shakes found more than two-thirds had more lead per serving than its experts consider safe for a full day.
- Dairy-based proteins generally had the lowest lead levels; plant-based products averaged about nine times more lead than dairy-based ones.
What Counts as a Protein Drink?
- Protein powders: whey, casein, egg, beef, or plant proteins (pea, rice, soy, hemp) that you mix with water or milk.
- Ready-to-drink (RTD) shakes: pre-mixed bottles or cartons, usually dairy-based.
- Meal-replacement shakes: protein plus carbohydrates, fats, fiber and vitamins, designed to replace a meal.
- Protein-fortified drinks: protein waters, coffees and milks with added protein.
How Much Protein Do You Actually Need?
| Goal | Daily protein (g per kg body weight) | Example for a 70 kg (154 lb) adult |
|---|---|---|
| Basic adult requirement (RDA) | 0.8 | About 56 g |
| Building or maintaining muscle (research range) | 1.2 to 1.6 | About 84 to 112 g |
| Point where extra protein stopped helping muscle gains | About 1.6 | About 112 g |
The U.S. and Canadian RDA is 0.8 g/kg/day, and the WHO and the European Food Safety Authority use about 0.83 g/kg/day. Higher intakes of 1.2 to 1.6 g/kg/day have been suggested for gaining or maintaining muscle. A protein drink is simply one way to close the gap if your diet falls short.
Benefits of Protein Drinks
1. Modestly Better Muscle and Strength Gains
The most-cited evidence is a 2018 meta-analysis in the British Journal of Sports Medicine by Morton and colleagues. Across 49 randomized trials, protein supplementation during at least six weeks of resistance training increased gains in strength, lean mass and muscle size. The effects were real but small, and they were weaker in older adults and stronger in people with more training experience.
2. Convenience
A shake takes seconds, travels well and needs no cooking. That is the main reason people use them, especially after workouts, at breakfast or during busy days.
3. Helpful When Appetite or Intake Is Low
For people who struggle to eat enough protein, such as some older adults, people with small appetites or those following a restrictive diet, a drink can be an easier way to add protein. Anyone with a medical condition should get advice from a clinician or dietitian first.
4. Easy Portion and Macro Tracking
Each serving lists exact protein, calories and sugar, which helps people who track their intake for weight loss or training.
5. Options for Different Diets
There are whey and casein for dairy eaters, lactose-free isolates, and plant-based powders for vegans. Note that plant-based products tested higher for heavy metals, as described below.
Drawbacks of Protein Drinks
1. Heavy Metal Contamination
In October 2025, Consumer Reports tested multiple lots of 23 popular protein powders and ready-to-drink shakes. It found that heavy metal contamination was more common than in its testing 15 years earlier.
- More than two-thirds of products contained more lead per serving than CR’s experts consider safe for a whole day; some had over 10 times that level.
- Plant-based products averaged about nine times more lead than dairy-based ones and twice as much as beef-based ones.
- CR advised against daily use of most protein powders and noted that none are needed to reach protein goals.
The other side: CR’s threshold is stricter than government limits. Industry groups said exceeding CR’s level is not the same as exceeding a safety limit, and one brand said the benchmark could be exceeded by a cup of spinach. An NPR report summarized expert advice as moderation, not panic. The FDA said it was reviewing the findings.
2. Not Necessary for Most People
Most people can reach their protein needs through foods like eggs, dairy, fish, poultry, beans and nuts, which also provide other nutrients. Experts quoted after CR’s report recommended whole foods first.
3. Added Sugar, Sweeteners and Additives
Some shakes contain significant added sugar, while others use artificial sweeteners, sugar alcohols or gums that cause bloating or digestive upset in some people. Always read the label.
4. Weak Supplement Regulation
In the U.S., dietary supplements are not approved by the FDA before sale, so quality varies between brands and even between batches. Third-party certification helps but does not guarantee zero contaminants.
5. Cost
Per gram of protein, powders and especially ready-to-drink shakes are often more expensive than basic foods like eggs, milk, beans or canned fish.
6. Extra Calories
Shakes add calories. Mixed with milk, nut butter or fruit, a shake can easily become a meal’s worth of calories, which can work against weight-loss goals if you drink it on top of your normal meals.
Protein Drink Types Compared
| Type | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Whey | Complete protein, fast-digesting, well studied, generally lowest lead in CR testing | Contains lactose (less in isolates); not vegan |
| Casein | Slow-digesting, often used before bed | Dairy; thicker texture |
| Plant-based (pea, rice, soy) | Vegan, lactose-free | Higher average lead in CR testing; some blends needed for a full amino acid profile |
| Ready-to-drink shakes | Most convenient | More expensive per serving; check sugar and additives |
How to Choose a Safer Protein Drink
- Food first: use shakes to fill gaps, not to replace meals every day.
- Look for third-party testing: certifications such as NSF Certified for Sport or Informed Sport test for banned substances and some contaminants.
- Consider dairy-based options if you tolerate dairy, since they generally tested lowest for lead.
- Rotate products and avoid relying on one plant-based powder daily.
- Check the label: aim for 20 to 30 g protein per serving with low added sugar.
- Talk to a clinician if you are pregnant, have kidney disease or take medications, and before giving protein supplements to children.
FAQs
Are protein drinks good for you?
They can be a convenient way to add protein, and they modestly help muscle gains with strength training. But they are not necessary for most people, and quality varies widely.
Is it safe to drink a protein shake every day?
Consumer Reports advises against daily use of most powders because of heavy metal levels. If you use one daily, choose a third-party tested, lower-lead product and keep whole foods as your main protein source.
Do protein shakes help you lose weight?
Not on their own. They can help you hit protein targets, but they also add calories. Weight loss depends on your overall diet.
When is the best time to drink a protein shake?
Total daily protein matters more than timing. Many people drink one after a workout or at breakfast for convenience.
Is whey or plant protein better?
Whey is a complete, well-studied protein and generally had lower lead levels in CR’s testing. Plant proteins suit vegans and people with dairy allergies, but choose carefully tested brands.
Bottom Line
Protein drinks are a convenient tool, especially for people who strength train or struggle to eat enough protein, and they can modestly improve muscle gains up to about 1.6 g/kg/day. They are not essential, and recent testing found concerning heavy metal levels in many products, especially plant-based ones. Use them to fill gaps, choose third-party tested products, and get most of your protein from whole foods.
This article is for general information and is not medical or nutrition advice. Talk to a doctor or registered dietitian about your individual needs.
Sources
- Morton et al., British Journal of Sports Medicine (2018) – Protein supplementation meta-analysis
- Journal of Cachexia, Sarcopenia and Muscle (2022) – Protein intake and muscle mass meta-analysis
- Consumer Reports – Protein powders and shakes contain high levels of lead
- NPR – A study found lead in popular protein powders
- UConn Today – A pharmacologist explains the protein powder data
- NTD – Brand responses to Consumer Reports’ testing
Discover more from Pros & Cons Reviews
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.